Over the years, consumers seem to have grown used to the Thanksgiving Day openings, even if they still have a distaste for the practice. More than half (55%) of Americans surveyed by RichRelevance, a tech company that services more than 200 retailers, said they are “annoyed” or “very annoyed” when stores stay open on Thanksgiving, down from 65% in 2014.
The advancing holiday promotional schedule has been a double-edged sword for retailers that want the sales without irritating shoppers. Now, there’s new evidence to suggest that consumers are becoming less annoyed by the practice.
U.S. consumers are still bothered by Christmas Creep, but less so with each passing year. Roughly 63 percent are annoyed or very annoyed when holiday goods appear in stores before Halloween, down from 71 percent in 2014, according to a new survey by RichRelevance.
Although most Americans are still irritated to see holiday items appear in the store alongside Halloween goodies and don’t like stores being open on Thanksgiving, attitudes are beginning to change.
That’s according to RichRelevance’s third-annual Holiday Shopping Survey, which finds that 63% of consumers are annoyed or very annoyed when holiday items appear in the store before Halloween – down from 71% in 2014. In addition, 55% are annoyed or very annoyed when stores open on Thanksgiving Day, down from 65% in 2014.
Looks like Thanksgiving shopping, Christmas Creep are here to stay.
The legions of Americans who hope to save Thanksgiving from the crassness and commercialism of the rest of the holiday shopping season appear to be losing the battle. A new survey shows that more Americans are becoming cool with the fact that stores are open for business with huge holiday sales and promotions on Thanksgiving Day.
New study of 1,000+ US shoppers reveals changing consumer sentiment around Christmas Creep, Thanksgiving store hours, Black Friday & special deals
San Francisco, CA — September 19, 2016 — With more than $626 billion in holiday sales at stake, retailers are changing the way they sell during the holiday season – for example, stocking the shelves with holiday merchandise in early Fall and opening their doors on Thanksgiving Day. But these practices raise key questions about what shoppers want, what rubs them the wrong way, how traditional shopping days like Black Friday are evolving, and what retailers like REI gain (or lose) when they reject the trend.
Released today, RichRelevance’s third-annual Holiday Shopping Survey drills into consumer attitudes and preferences around holiday marketing and merchandising to provide new insight into what shoppers want – and when – from omnichannel retail. Key findings include:
Retailers are gaining ground in the Christmas Creep game
Although most Americans are still irritated to see holiday items appear in the store alongside Halloween goodies, attitudes are changing.
- Six out of 10 Americans (63%) are annoyed or very annoyed when holiday items appear in the store before Halloween – down from 71% in 2014.
- Over half of Americans surveyed (55%) are annoyed or very annoyed when stores open on Thanksgiving Day – down from 65% in 2014.
- Many Americans are shopping early: more than 1 in 4 Americans (27%) had already started their holiday shopping by Labor Day.
Goodwill can be gained by bucking the Christmas Creep trend
REI made news last year when it closed stores on both Thanksgiving Day and Black Friday. Other retailers such as Nordstrom, Dillard’s and H&M made a point of remaining closed on Thanksgiving. When asked about these practices:
- 7 in 10 Americans (73%) said these retailers’ decisions made them like the retailers more.
- Over half (53%) said they are more likely to shop with retailers who remain closed on Thanksgiving Day.
- A comparable amount (48%) stated they are more likely to shop with REI as a result of their decision.
Black Friday is losing ground
Black Friday has traditionally marked the beginning of the holiday shopping season, but consumer sentiments and shopping patterns are changing.
- Only 1 in 10 (11%) Americans feel Black Friday has grown in importance, while 4 in 10 (42%) state Black Friday is less important than it was 5 years ago.
- 6 out of 10 Americans (58%) state that special deals on Black Friday and Cyber Monday do not impact their shopping behavior.
- However, Cyber Monday is gaining ground with 1 in 3 (33%) of Americans saying Cyber Monday is more important than it was 5 years ago.
Millennials are a bright spot for retailers
The coveted Millennial shopper (age 18- 29) behaves differently than other generations.
- Younger Millennial shoppers are more tolerant of Christmas Creep. Early holiday merchandise only bothers half of these shoppers (51% vs. 63% of overall respondents).
- Millennials are also more responsive to deals. 6 out of 10 (60%) say that special deals on Black Friday and Cyber Monday encourage them to shop.
- This digital generation loves Cyber Monday: more than half (52%) think it is more important than it was 5 years ago.
Methodology
This is the third-annual Holiday Shopping survey conducted by RichRelevance to understand consumer shopping patterns and behaviors. The survey of 1,054 U.S. shoppers was conducted in August 2016. Responses were gathered online over a 2-week period.
Kmart began running its Christmas ads right after Labor Day. Around the same time, a huge Christmas tree was spotted at a Bay Area Ikea. Hobby Lobby had its Christmas decorations up in August.
Clearly, some retailers are taking no chances this holiday season. However, their efforts might be counterproductive. “What consumers bristle about is feeling like it’s shoved down their throat,” says Kit Yarrow, a retail industry consultant.